Skip to content
ES
Review Pop, R&B
Ariana Grande

Sweetener

Ariana Grande began her fourth album with Pharrell before Manchester and finished it after. It is a record about healing that keeps telling jokes.

By Elmo Phelge 3 min read

Ariana Grande began her fourth album in 2016 by asking Pharrell Williams to “take me somewhere completely new”. On 22 May 2017, a bomb went off in the foyer of Manchester Arena just after her concert, and 22 people were killed. Sweetener, released by Republic on 17 August 2018, is what she made on the other side of it: 15 songs in 47 minutes, named, she told Time, for a message to her fans, that a bad situation can be made better.

The Spotify player only loads when you press play. Spotify may set cookies.

She and Pharrell worked without a deadline and, by her account, made “a million” songs. He described his job as part listener, part therapist, part stenographer. She told him she wanted to “make the weirdest thing we can first”. She said it was the first time she led the writing. Pharrell produced seven songs. Most of the rest came from Max Martin and Ilya Salmanzadeh, who produced “God Is a Woman” and “Breathin”, and who took her requests for odd 1990s chord progressions. Tommy Brown, Hit-Boy and the Social House duo of Charles Anderson and Michael Foster did the rest. Five of the songs were late additions: she had cut them as too emotionally honest, then put them back after what she called an emotional rock bottom.

Pharrell Williams in a navy beanie and a white leather jacket printed with a black skeleton, in front of a Hidden Figures backdrop
Pharrell Williams at a screening of Hidden Figures at the National Museum of African American History and Culture in Washington, DC, in December 2016. Photo: Joel Kowsky / NASA, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

“The Light Is Coming” was written to have a guest. Grande auditioned eight rappers, liked none of them and sent it to Nicki Minaj, who called her into the studio at 5 a.m. to hear the verse; Grande went in her slippers and pyjamas. Under it loops a 2009 CNN clip of a man shouting at Senator Arlen Specter at a Pennsylvania town hall on health care, which Pharrell had already sampled on N.E.R.D and Rihanna’s “Lemon”. Her friend Troye Sivan called it the kookiest song on the album. “R.E.M.” grew from the hook of an unreleased Beyoncé demo called “Wake Up”, which Grande said was too dreamy not to find a home. The Guardian heard the title track as a Carole King-style piano song spliced into Migos-style hip-hop. Missy Elliott, whose music Grande had danced to in her room as a child, guests on “Borderline”.

“Breathin” is about anxiety. “Get Well Soon”, the closer, was written right after an anxiety attack; Pharrell, she said, told her to write about it and promised it would heal her. It runs to 5:22, padded out with silence, and critics took the length as a tribute to the date of the attack. “Goodnight n Go” reworks Imogen Heap’s 2006 song “Goodnight and Go”. “Pete Davidson”, a 74-second interlude, is named after her fiancé at the time, the Saturday Night Live comedian. She said she didn’t know what else to call it, and that Tyler, the Creator told her a song about loving waffles and syrup would be called “Waffles and Syrup”. Her own summary: “Here is my bleeding heart, and here is a trap beat behind it.”

Sweetener entered the Billboard 200 at No. 1 with 231,000 units, and in February 2019 it won the Grammy for Best Pop Vocal Album, her first. Metacritic’s average was 81. Rolling Stone called it the best album of her career. Pitchfork’s Jill Mapes preferred the Pharrell half and named “Get Well Soon” the “career-defining moment”. Critics split over which half worked. The Guardian’s Alexis Petridis found the Pharrell songs bold and Martin’s formulaic, while the Observer thought Pharrell inconsistent and called “Breathin” a triumph. The town-hall sample split them too: Rolling Stone’s weak spot was an essential track for Consequence of Sound. Missy Elliott’s verse found no defenders: NME called it dated, the Independent a disaster.

The engagement is the easy way into this record, and plenty of reviews took it. That reading misses how funny Sweetener is. An album about healing loops a stranger yelling at a senator. Its love song carries its subject’s name because she couldn’t think of a better title. “Successful” is a happy brag, and the title track drops trap ad-libs into a piano ballad. The Independent noticed the wit, and it is the album’s best quality, because it keeps the hard songs from turning into lessons. The wit doesn’t carry all 15 tracks. Missy Elliott’s verse wastes a guest Grande had idolised since childhood, “Everytime” is the most ordinary thing here, and parts of the Martin half are as predictable as the Guardian said. Grande and Davidson called off the engagement in October 2018. The 74-second song with his name on it is still track 14.

Watch and listen

Players only load when you press play. Their providers may set cookies.

Elmo Phelge relaunched Earbuddy in 2026.

More reviews