Skip to content
ES
Review Indie rock, Synth-pop
Sharon Van Etten

Remind Me Tomorrow

Written between acting, psychology classes and new parenthood, Sharon Van Etten's fifth album trades her guitar for synths and organ and reaches for Springsteen.

By Elmo Phelge 3 min read

Sharon Van Etten’s fifth album came out on Jagjaguwar on 18 January 2019, almost five years after Are We There. After one more EP, I Don’t Want to Let You Down (2015), she largely stopped touring. She played Rachel in Netflix’s The OA, sang “Tarifa” on David Lynch’s Twin Peaks: The Return in June 2017, scored Katherine Dieckmann’s film Strange Weather, enrolled at Brooklyn College to study psychology and became a parent. The ten songs run 41 minutes; the title comes from the update window on her computer, where she kept clicking “remind me tomorrow”.

The Spotify player only loads when you press play. Spotify may set cookies.

The songs began at the piano in 2015. The Strange Weather score kept her on guitar, so to clear her head she turned to the synthesizer and organ in a rehearsal space she shared with the actor Michael Cera; his Roland Jupiter-4 gave one song its name. By 2017 she had about 40 demos. By her account, she came to work with John Congleton during six months in Los Angeles in early 2018, while on call for the second season of The OA. They cut “Jupiter 4” and “Memorial Day” as a trial; she gave him Suicide, Portishead and Nick Cave’s Skeleton Tree as references and let him choose the band. He recorded and mixed it in three Los Angeles studios. Van Etten plays no guitar on it: she is credited with vocals, piano and organ. Heather Woods Broderick sings on every song.

Sharon Van Etten, with long dark hair, a sheer black blouse with white dots and dark jeans, stands at a microphone stand in front of a red curtain
Sharon Van Etten performing at the Grammy Museum in Los Angeles, in September 2019. Photo: Justin Higuchi, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

“Comeback Kid” started as a piano ballad, but Van Etten told the label she “didn’t want it to be pretty”. Sam Cohen, who shares the writing credit, suggested grafting on part of another song, “Runaway”, as the bridge; she has said the song is about going home and still being your parents’ kid. “Memorial Day” grew from a ten-minute demo of a drumbeat and an organ riff, made before she was pregnant; hearing it again a year later, as a parent, she found its chorus had turned eerie. She wrote “Jupiter 4” as an exercise in writing for someone else and gave it to Donna Missal, who released it as “Jupiter” in 2018; Van Etten still wanted her own, odder version. “Stay” began as a love song to her partner and, late in her pregnancy, became one to her child.

“Seventeen”, written with Kate Davis, started as a Lucinda Williams-style dirge and ended up, in the label’s words, “a nod to Bruce Springsteen”. It is about her teenage self, and about living in New York long enough to become one of the people complaining that it has changed. As a child, she told The Ringer, her father caught her in the basement playing “Born in the U.S.A.” at full volume, and of the arena-rock pull of “Comeback Kid” and “Seventeen” she told Uproxx, “I am from Jersey so I can’t fight those influences, they’re in my blood.” “Comeback Kid” came with the announcement on 2 October 2018, “Jupiter 4” on 27 November and “Seventeen” on 8 January 2019; the tour opened in Washington on 6 February.

Pitchfork’s Laura Snapes gave it 8.4 and Best New Music and called it the peak of her songwriting. The Guardian’s Rachel Aroesti heard an artist newly sure of herself, with “Jupiter 4” recalling Suicide and “Seventeen” Springsteen, a comparison Rolling Stone’s Jon Dolan also made. Robert Christgau, who had never been drawn to her before, gave it an A minus and credited its toned-down drama. Drowned in Sound found three songs underdone, and God Is in the TV gave it 5 out of 10, singling out three songs worth keeping. It reached No. 94 on the Billboard 200 and No. 30 in the UK. The Guardian ranked it fourth of 2019 and Rolling Stone 27th, and Pitchfork put “Seventeen” sixth among the year’s songs.

For four albums Van Etten’s songs were mostly about relationships that hurt her and the work of getting out of them. This one opens with her telling a new partner everything, without telling us, and moves on. Her guitar gives way to organ, drones and a borrowed synthesizer, and at its widest, on “Seventeen” and “Comeback Kid”, the record reaches for the open-hearted sweep of the Springsteen she grew up on, an influence she has openly claimed. Some songs drew doubts, but this is her boldest, most outward-looking album and the start of what came next: in 2025 she released Sharon Van Etten & The Attachment Theory, written with her band, and Relix traced that band’s roots back to this one.

Watch and listen

Players only load when you press play. Their providers may set cookies.

Elmo Phelge relaunched Earbuddy in 2026.

More reviews