Skip to content
ES
Review Pop, R&B
Justin Timberlake

Man of the Woods

Timberlake's fifth album brought back the Neptunes, Timbaland and Danja under a Memphis mood board and one tagline: Americana with 808s.

By Elmo Phelge 3 min read

Man of the Woods came out on RCA on February 2, 2018, five years after The 20/20 Experience and two days before Justin Timberlake headlined the Super Bowl LII halftime show in Minneapolis. The title came out of a conversation in the studio. Pharrell Williams asked what Timberlake’s son’s name meant, Timberlake looked it up, and the answer, by his account, was Latin for “man of the woods”. He called it “the most introspective record I’ve made”. The trailer sold it with a tagline, modern Americana with 808s, and clips of him outdoors with his family. “Can’t Stop the Feeling!”, his fifth US No. 1 in 2016, belonged to the Trolls soundtrack and stayed off it.

The Spotify player only loads when you press play. Spotify may set cookies.

It was a reunion. The Neptunes, Williams and Chad Hugo, had not worked on a Timberlake album since Justified in 2002. Timberlake told Zane Lowe that Williams’s fight with Jive Records over Clipse had kept him away from the label’s artists. Back together, the Neptunes produced nine of the 16 songs, starting with the title track. Timbaland and Danja, the team behind FutureSex/LoveSounds, worked on four between them, and Rob Knox and Eric Hudson did “Morning Light” and “The Hard Stuff”. Danja, who joined in January 2017, said the brief was clear. “The word country was never used in the discussions. Just Memphis.” Timberlake had pinned a board of Memphis influences on the studio wall and, by Danja’s account, played on much of the record himself.

The guests arrived sideways. Chris Stapleton, who had sung with Timberlake at the 2015 CMA Awards, came to Los Angeles to write and ended up on “Say Something” when Timberlake told him to take a verse. He also co-wrote “Morning Light”, the duet with Alicia Keys, and “The Hard Stuff”, and he says the first sound on “Filthy” is his Jazzmaster through a delay pedal. “Filthy” itself, the opener and lead single, is Timbaland and Danja’s, with a Mark Romanek video built around a robot demonstration at a tech conference.

Justin Timberlake in a white T-shirt playing an acoustic guitar at a microphone, surrounded by his band, with a trumpet player and a saxophonist on the left
Justin Timberlake in concert in Miami on the Man of the Woods Tour, May 18, 2018. Photo: J Vettorino, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The rustic songs carry the concept. In Rolling Stone’s reading, “Supplies” casts Timberlake as the partner with the provisions when the world ends, with Williams adding vocals, and Dave Meyers shot a dystopian video for it. “Livin’ Off the Land” opens on a sampled commercial for the History Channel survival show Mountain Men. Jessica Biel speaks the short “Hers” interlude that leads into “Flannel”, and the closer, “Young Man”, is addressed to Timberlake’s son, who can be heard on it. “Midnight Summer Jam”, one of the Neptunes’ songs, makes room for a harmonica solo.

The reviews were mixed, with a Metacritic average of 55 from 29 reviews. Rolling Stone heard some of his most exploratory music in years while calling it his least cohesive album, and Variety found plenty to like, starting with the nerve of the idea. Pitchfork gave it 3.8 and called it “a huge misstep for the pop star”, with too little in its songs to fill more than an hour. PopMatters called it his worst album. The split between the Guardian and its Sunday sister paper says the most. In the Guardian, Alexis Petridis gave it three stars, praised “Supplies”, “Midnight Summer Jam” and “The Hard Stuff”, called “Wave” horrible and “Sauce” ungainly. A week later in the Observer, Kitty Empire gave it two stars, named “Sauce” and “Filthy” as standouts and found “Wave” one of the few places where it broke new ground. It still opened at No. 1 on the Billboard 200 with 293,000 units, the biggest week of 2018 so far.

The idea was never the problem. Petridis pointed out that country and R&B shared plenty of ground around 1970, and Timberlake had named Memphis blues and Nashville country as the music he grew up around. What the album never produces is a song that makes the case on its own. The critics who found something to like could not agree on what it was: one reviewer’s highlight was another’s worst moment. “Filthy” and “Say Something” both reached No. 9 on the Hot 100, and “Say Something” got a Grammy nomination, but the duet’s lyric, about the pressure to have something to say, settles on silence as the better answer. That is a strange conclusion for a 66-minute record that has little to say. Timberlake’s next album, Everything I Thought It Was, took another six years and arrived in March 2024.

Watch and listen

Players only load when you press play. Their providers may set cookies.

Elmo Phelge relaunched Earbuddy in 2026.

More reviews