Here Comes the Cowboy was the first release on Mac’s Record Label, the imprint Mac DeMarco announced in August 2018 after six years on Captured Tracks. It came out on 10 May 2019, and the label was about control: he told Rolling Stone that outside input tainted his creativity, “especially with people that are trying to sell something.” With that freedom he made what critics heard as his slowest record: 13 songs, 46 minutes, played almost entirely by one man in a garage.
He was living in Los Angeles by then, and he had turned a two-car garage that was once “dusty and filled with spiders” into a studio crammed with old microphones and mixing desks. The title track started there as a twangy guitar part during a short break between the long This Old Dog tour and a solo tour. DeMarco said most of the other songs were written in November; the label’s notes put the writing, tracking and mixing in the first two weeks of an exceptionally rainy January 2019. His touring bandmate Alec Meen added keys to “Finally Alone” and “Choo Choo”, and his travelling sound engineer, Joe Santarpia, shared the engineering and mixing. He wanted it to sound like a demo, and told DIY the trick was to stop tweaking: “you have to let it rest.”
“This one is my cowboy record,” he said when he announced it, but for him the word was a term of endearment for friends, and he told NME it wasn’t a country record. In Edmonton, where he grew up, cowboys were the hat-wearing jocks who wanted to beat him up. On the album the West is a cartoon, in his word, and a fantasy of the simple life that he found comforting at a time when people were “going crazy”. He told Flaunt the title track, four words repeated over a strum, was once three times as long and wouldn’t fit on vinyl. “Choo Choo” sets nonsense about trains to a funk groove modelled on Sly and the Family Stone. The rusty grinning pin on the cover was bought from a man in the Nantahala National Forest.
Under the jokes, DeMarco called it more emotional than This Old Dog. He described “Finally Alone” as a “cute little Postman Pat–sounding song” about someone who keeps hoping the grass is greener elsewhere, and said that had been his own last ten years. “All of Our Yesterdays”, the oldest song here, takes its title from Macbeth and was meant, after he watched an Oasis documentary, as a giant rock hit; he admitted he never got close. Critics heard the waltzing lead single, “Nobody”, as a lament about fame. Two songs carry a loss. DeMarco told Entertainment Weekly that “Heart to Heart” and “Skyless Moon” are there in memory of Mac Miller, a close friend in Los Angeles who died in September 2018. “Skyless Moon”, he told NME, is about death, and it made the album only because Miller heard it at five in the morning and loved it. The closer, “Baby Bye Bye”, runs seven and a half minutes and hides a second piece, “The Cattleman’s Prayer”, at the end.
The reviews split hard. NME’s Thomas Hobbs heard a calmer, more grown-up record and put “On the Square” among the best songs of his career, and Uncut called it braver and weirder than his peers’ work. Rolling Stone’s Joe Levy found it stark, lonely and closed off. The Independent’s Jazz Monroe called it his worst album, coasting on his image, though he still praised “Finally Alone”, “K” and “On the Square”. Loud and Quiet and the Line of Best Fit both thought the title track did next to nothing. The album reached No. 23 in the UK and was nominated for the 2020 Juno for Alternative Album of the Year.
The detractors are right about the stretches where nothing moves: the title track and “Choo Choo” are jokes that run long, and a record meant to sound like a demo keeps its weaker ideas too. But the looseness is also where the candour comes from. DeMarco put down what was on his mind, a dead friend, the weight of being known, a wish for a quieter life, and didn’t polish it into a product. Stay with him through the slack patches and there is “Nobody”, “Finally Alone” and “On the Square”. It is uneven, personal and worth the time.
Watch and listen
Players only load when you press play. Their providers may set cookies.