Rostam Batmanglij, who had produced Vampire Weekend’s first three albums, left the band in January 2016. Ezra Koenig said the same day that work on the fourth album had begun and that the two would keep writing together. The XL deal was over, and Columbia released Father of the Bride on 3 May 2019: 18 songs in 58 minutes, the band’s first double album. Koenig fronted it alone, even in the press photos. Chris Baio and Chris Tomson toured it but didn’t play on it, the Guardian reported in 2024, and Apple Music credits them only with backing vocals on “Harmony Hall”. Koenig told the paper that a photo of three men in their mid-30s would have looked like “damaged goods”.
It was recorded mostly at Effie Street Studios and Vox in Los Angeles and at Sony’s studio in Tokyo, and was finished by August 2018. Ariel Rechtshaid, co-producer of Modern Vampires of the City, produced every song but one, 16 of them with Koenig. DJ Dahi, BloodPop, Dave Macklovitch of Chromeo and Buddy Ross had a hand in two or three songs each, and Greg Leisz plays steel guitar on “Harmony Hall” and “Stranger”. Batmanglij added production to “Harmony Hall” and produced and mixed “We Belong Together”, built on a 12-string riff he recorded with Koenig on Martha’s Vineyard in 2012 and joined years later to a piano song of Koenig’s.
Koenig wanted three duets with one singer, spread across the album, and gave them to Danielle Haim: “Hold You Now”, “Married in a Gold Rush” and “We Belong Together”. He said they owe a debt to classic country duets, and told Coup de Main he wanted “two people actually talking to each other”. Haim sings backing vocals on six more. Steve Lacy of the Internet sings on “Sunflower” and “Flower Moon” and speaks the opening of “Sympathy”. The credits name the samples: a choral piece from the soundtrack of The Thin Red Line, credited to Hans Zimmer, in “Hold You Now”, the Sierra Leonean guitarist S. E. Rogie in “Rich Man”, and in “2021”, “Talking”, which Haruomi Hosono wrote in the 1980s for Muji’s shops, with Jenny Lewis’s voice cut in.
Koenig took Bruce Springsteen’s The River and Paolo Conte’s Aguaplano as models, double albums that work like short-story collections. He told Pitchfork that 18 songs demanded more rigour, not less, though a little noodling, he added, can be a sign of life. “Stranger”, he said, is about hearing other people having a good time in another room and still feeling you belong. “Jerusalem, New York, Berlin” began, he told Coup de Main, with its title: three cities of particular weight for a Jewish person. The Guardian heard social media and populist politics in the lyrics; Pitchfork heard spring and rebirth.
Six songs came out in pairs first: “Harmony Hall” and “2021” in January 2019, “Sunflower” and “Big Blue” in March, “This Life” and “Unbearably White” in April. The album entered the Billboard 200 at No. 1, the band’s third chart-topper in a row, helped by a concert-ticket bundle. It reached No. 2 in the UK and won the Grammy for Best Alternative Music Album, with a nomination for Album of the Year. Rolling Stone’s David Fricke gave it four and a half stars while noting that the first impression is of a band hurrying to catch up. The Guardian’s Alexis Petridis compared it to the White Album, with more hits than misses among its rough ideas. Pitchfork’s Mike Powell gave it 8.0 but found it the band’s first overlong album. Paste found it disjointed, the Irish Times too long, and Loud and Quiet the loosest and mildest of the four.
Those complaints are fair, and they describe the surface. Eighteen songs, more than a dozen collaborators, duets that lean on classic country next to flamenco and a loop written for a Japanese shop, and a rollout that gave out a third of it in advance: up front, Father of the Bride looks scattered, and some of it is filler. Given room, it settles into the story collection Koenig described. “Harmony Hall”, “This Life” and “Stranger” carry the weight, and the three duets, spaced from the first track to the fifteenth, give it a spine. It is easy to like and hard to love, looser and longer than it needed to be, and better the longer it is given. Five years later, on Only God Was Above Us, Baio and Tomson were playing bass and drums again.
Watch and listen
Players only load when you press play. Their providers may set cookies.