Skip to content
ES
Review Pop, R&B
Ariana Grande

Thank U, Next

Ariana Grande made her fifth album with friends in about two weeks in New York. Its best song is the quietest one, and the one she wanted left off.

By Elmo Phelge 3 min read

Ariana Grande began her fifth album in the autumn of 2018, weeks after her fourth came out. In September her former boyfriend, the rapper Mac Miller, died; in October she ended her engagement to the comedian Pete Davidson. Thank U, Next, released by Republic on 8 February 2019, is what came out of the weeks that followed: 12 songs in 41 minutes, most of them written and recorded at Jungle City Studios in New York in about two weeks. Grande later said the album “kind of saved my life”.

The Spotify player only loads when you press play. Spotify may set cookies.

Victoria Monét, who had written with Grande on every one of her albums, told Rolling Stone there was a point that autumn when Grande didn’t want to do anything. About two weeks later Grande flew to New York to write with Max Martin and Savan Kotecha, and Monét followed. By her account they had nine songs or so after the first week and spent the second finishing them. Monét and Tayla Parx co-wrote six songs each. Grande presented the speed as a choice: she wanted to release music the way rappers do, to “drop it the way these boys do”, as she told Billboard.

Victoria Monét, long dark curly hair, in a mustard lace-up crop top, singing into a microphone on a stand under red light, with red fabric billowing behind her
Victoria Monét performing during a Dangerous Woman Tour concert in February 2017. Photo: Emma, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The singles are stacked at the end: “7 Rings”, the title track and “Break Up with Your Girlfriend, I’m Bored” close the album back to back. “Imagine”, produced by Pop Wansel and Happy Perez, is in 6/8 and climbs into whistle notes. “Fake Smile” is built on Wendy Rene’s 1964 single “After Laughter (Comes Tears)”, which Wu-Tang Clan sampled for “Tearz”. “7 Rings” takes its tune from Rodgers and Hammerstein’s “My Favorite Things”; its half-rapped verses drew accusations that Grande had borrowed other rappers’ flows, and a remix with 2 Chainz followed. The NSYNC interpolation in the closer was her idea, and Kotecha said it made him and Martin nervous, since they never use samples. Grande said she liked ending an honest, vulnerable record on a punchline.

“Ghostin” took the longest. By Grande’s account it was the first song they started: the hook came first, then they had to step away from it, and the verses followed about two weeks later. Kotecha said she never loved the verses he, Martin and Ilya Salmanzadeh had written with her, so she and Monét rewrote them; the vocal run at the end was her idea. She described it as a song about feeling bad for a partner because you love someone else. Listeners mapped it onto Miller and Davidson; she didn’t confirm that, and Monét said the writers tried to be respectful of both. Billboard noted that it opens with no drums and barely any bass, with the voice close to the microphone. Mattias Bylund’s strings and, as the Guardian pointed out, backwards synths fill in around her. Grande asked her then-manager, Scooter Braun, to take it off the album.

The album entered the Billboard 200 at No. 1, and on the same week’s Hot 100 its three singles held the top three places, which no act had done since the Beatles in 1964. Rolling Stone’s Rob Sheffield called it her best album yet. The Guardian’s Michael Cragg found the emotional centrepiece in “Ghostin” and “In My Head” and called “7 Rings” the low point; Billboard’s Andrew Unterberger called “Ghostin” “the album’s barest, most emotional track”. The doubts were about haste. Pitchfork’s Rawiya Kameir found some of the writing sloppy, citing “Bloodline”, and the Observer’s Kitty Empire found much of it unsurprising after Sweetener. At the Grammys in January 2020 it lost Album of the Year to Billie Eilish.

The best song on Thank U, Next is “Ghostin”, and it is the one least like the rest. On an album made fast, with its hits saved for the end, it is the song that took weeks and the one that refuses to hurry: no beat at the start, the voice up close, strings and reversed synths around it. It sits nearer to art pop than to the singles that follow, and nothing else here is as patient or as exposed. The rest is strong without being as daring. “Imagine” and “Fake Smile” carry real weight, “Bloodline” is thin, “7 Rings” leans on a borrowed tune and a couple of the mid-tempo songs run together. That is a fair price for a pop album this personal, made in two weeks among friends. Grande wanted “Ghostin” off the record and left it out of the 2019 tour. It reached No. 25 on the Hot 100 anyway, without being released as a single.

Watch and listen

Players only load when you press play. Their providers may set cookies.

Elmo Phelge relaunched Earbuddy in 2026.

More reviews