Weezer formed in Los Angeles in 1992, and two records from their first years, the Blue Album in 1994 and Pinkerton in 1996, are still what most of their audience measures them against. This is their 13th album and the sixth they called simply Weezer, after the Blue, Green, Red, White and Teal ones. It came out on 1 March 2019 on Crush Music and Atlantic, about five weeks after the Teal Album, a surprise set of covers. That record existed because of “Africa”: in 2018 a teenage fan ran a Twitter campaign asking the band to cover Toto’s hit, Weezer teased her with “Rosanna” first, then released “Africa” on 29 May, and it turned into one of their biggest songs in years.
The title is older than the music. Cuomo has said the White and Black names arrived together, when his manager pitched the first and pointed out what it made possible next. In 2016 he promised something darker, “less summer day and more winter night”, maybe even with swearing, which he had never done in a song. That version was shelved. By his account nobody but him and his manager liked it, and its planned first single was put aside when “Africa” took off. The new start came from Dave Sitek of TV on the Radio, who was sent stems, turned them into “Can’t Knock the Hustle” and, as he tells it, fully expected to be fired. The band loved it.
Cuomo wrote every song on piano, a first for a Weezer album, and says he hardly plays guitar on the record. He sent Sitek MIDI piano and demo vocals; the other three then came in one at a time and played whatever they wanted, not only their usual instruments, and Sitek picked the best parts before Cuomo returned for the final vocals. Patrick Wilson remembers the sessions as long talks at Sitek’s house followed by short bursts of playing. Cuomo also mined his archive: the chorus of “Too Many Thoughts in My Head” dates from 1997, and “I’m Just Being Honest” reworks a song he first released in Japanese in 2017 as half of Scott & Rivers. Asked about influences, he pointed to Kanye West above all, plus 90s Beck, the Beastie Boys and some My Bloody Valentine guitar.
Co-writers fill the credits. Rami Yacoub co-wrote “Zombie Bastards”, Josh Alexander “High as a Kite”, Laura Jane Grace of Against Me! “Byzantine”, and Brian Bell and Luther Russell “The Prince Who Wanted Everything”, which critics heard as a tribute to Prince. Jonny Coffer co-wrote and co-produced “Living in L.A.”, and Money Mark, the Beastie Boys’ longtime collaborator, plays keyboards on the opener and on “Byzantine”. “Can’t Knock the Hustle” mixes funk, mariachi-style horns and a chorus in Spanish; its video casts Pete Wentz as a ride-share driver in Cuomo’s glasses. Cuomo has said drugs are one of the album’s main themes, though he doesn’t use them himself. Critics also heard a man in middle age overwhelmed by screens and noise, above all in “Too Many Thoughts in My Head”.
Reviews spread wide. Q gave it four stars and liked the turn to synth and piano, and Drowned in Sound credited Sitek with updating the band’s sound. Rolling Stone heard a new method wrapped around the same precise pop-rock. NME found the jokes wearing thin but liked the straighter songs, “I’m Just Being Honest” and the Prince tribute. Consequence of Sound blamed the lyrics, Exclaim! called it skippable, and PopMatters and Under the Radar gave it 1 out of 10. “High as a Kite” split them: Consequence of Sound and Drowned in Sound picked it as the best song, NME called it limp. In the UK it entered the albums chart at 73 and was gone the following week.
By 2019 people came to a new Weezer album braced for damage, which is an odd fate for the band that made Pinkerton. Measured that way, the Black Album gets through. “I’m Just Being Honest” and “High as a Kite” hold up, and the promised darkness, as several critics noted, never really arrives. What is left is an uneven, middling record that sits well below the band’s first two albums and does little to change the picture. Cuomo was already finishing OK Human, piano songs with an orchestra, when this one came out, and that album, two years later, made a better case for the piano.
Watch and listen
Players only load when you press play. Their providers may set cookies.