Skip to content
ES
Review Alternative rock, Neo-psychedelia
The Dandy Warhols

Why You So Crazy

For their 25th anniversary the Dandy Warhols built an album in turns at their Portland studio. It jumps between styles and rarely holds together.

By Elmo Phelge 3 min read

The Dandy Warhols formed in Portland, Oregon, in 1994 and made their name on Capitol, where “Bohemian Like You” reached a far wider audience through a Vodafone advert. The documentary Dig! (2004) then set them against the Brian Jonestown Massacre. After This Machine (2012) and Distortland (2016), their tenth studio album, Why You So Crazy, came out on Dine Alone on 25 January 2019, timed to the band’s 25th anniversary: twelve tracks in just under 41 minutes. “Everyone kind of does their own thing in their basement studios,” Courtney Taylor-Taylor told Gigwise. Then they took turns at the band’s studio, mostly alone with the engineer, adding parts to one another’s songs.

The Spotify player only loads when you press play. Spotify may set cookies.

That studio is the Odditorium, a former warehouse in northwest Portland that the band bought in the early 2000s and turned into headquarters, recording space and clubhouse. All four members are credited as producers; Brandon Eggleston engineered and mixed the album with Taylor-Taylor, and Adam Ayan mastered it. Taylor-Taylor called his bandmates “probably the best studio producers I’ve ever worked with”, and by his and Peter Holmström’s account nobody set a deadline until the songs had to go to mixing. To anyone who mixes or produces, he told Mixdown, the record was “worth buying a $1,000 pair of headphones for”.

The announcement promised a band moving freely between styles: off-kilter psych-pop on “Be Alright”, Americana with a country accent on “Motor City Steel”, a gothic rumba driven by piano on “Forever”, and nods to Fred Astaire and Ginger Rogers, Don McLean’s Chevy and the church in Bowie’s “Modern Love”. Slant, Paste and PopMatters likened the 40-second opener, “Fred n Ginger”, to an old 78 or a wax cylinder. On “Terraform” Taylor-Taylor stacked six vocal tracks, by his count, with delay running backwards and forwards; on “Motor City Steel” he kept his voice bone dry. “Highlife”, which Zia McCabe wrote and sings, began as a song by her country band, Brush Prairie. Thomas Lauderdale of Pink Martini plays piano on “Forever”, and the album closes with “Ondine”, the first movement of Maurice Ravel’s 1908 suite Gaspard de la nuit, played by the classical pianist Hunter Noack.

Zia McCabe smiling with her chin resting on her hands, lying among large pale balloons under blue light
Zia McCabe at the Metro in Chicago on 11 May 2019. Photo: Ripe Melon Man, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

“Forever” came out first, with a video, in October 2018. “Be Alright” arrived with the album’s announcement in November; Taylor-Taylor told WFPK’s Kyle Meredith that Brent DeBoer wrote it on his laptop during a long flight. Its video is a single 360-degree shot through the Odditorium, directed by Taylor-Taylor, with Jessica Paré of Mad Men as the guide. “Motor City Steel” followed in January. Taylor-Taylor called it a true story from the small town in southwest Washington where he lived from 2006 to 2014: the men browse online for truck parts and fishing gear, he said, while more and more of the women look at New York, Paris and Hollywood. Announcing the album, he set it against a wider mood, saying he had never felt so strongly that people were losing their minds, from politics to the news and the president.

Most reviews were mixed; Metacritic puts the average of 11 at 56. Paste’s Libby Cudmore was the warmest, praising a fearless art-pop record; PopMatters found it entertaining and exhausting at once. AllMusic’s Heather Phares thought the band ran out of inspiration before they stopped recording, Slant’s Zachary Hoskins heard plenty of production detail and few memorable songs, and Clash found little coherence and too much that felt unfinished. Nobody agreed on the good parts either. Clash’s highlights, “To the Church” and “Forever”, were the two songs AllMusic called sketches never filled in, and Under the Radar praised “Thee Elegant Bum” and “Terraform”, which AllMusic dismissed as “grooves that go nowhere”.

Twelve tracks pull in twelve directions, and almost every one was somebody’s high point and somebody else’s low. A few do land. “Be Alright” comes closest to a consensus pick, and “Sins Are Forgiven” and McCabe’s “Highlife” had the most defenders after it. More of the record misses. The long, slow “Next Thing I Know” lost Paste, Slant and The AU Review, and “Small Town Girls” and “Motor City Steel” drew more complaints than champions. Nothing ties the rest together, not a subject and not a sound: four producers taking turns on one another’s songs, with no deadline until the mix, left a pile of parts rather than a plan. It ends on a Ravel piano piece played by a guest, fine in itself and, as Clash noted, hard to connect to the eleven songs before it.

Watch and listen

Players only load when you press play. Their providers may set cookies.

Elmo Phelge relaunched Earbuddy in 2026.

More reviews