By Duke Garwood’s account, he met Mark Lanegan backstage at a Soulsavers show, the band Lanegan was singing with, when Lanegan walked over and asked if he was Duke G. Lanegan, a fan of Garwood’s records, took him on tour as his support act and had him play guitar on Blues Funeral (2012). Their first album as a duo, Black Pudding, followed in 2013 on Heavenly and, in the US, Ipecac. Garwood summed up the method: “I make sounds and rhythms for Mark to find songs in.” With Animals, released by Heavenly on 24 August 2018, kept the method and changed the tools. Black Pudding was built around Garwood’s guitar; most of these 12 songs, 38 minutes in all, run on loops, tape and a drum machine.
The record started without Lanegan. Introducing the title track, he said the album was recorded in his house by Garwood alone, with his five animals for company, and that a close listen on headphones might catch “a bark, meow, growl or whine”. Hence the name. The sleeve credits Garwood with the instrumentals of seven songs, recorded on a cassette eight-track in Los Angeles; he said studio tracks went through the same tape to strip out the digital, and that every effect is analogue. The label described the work as split between sessions together and music sent between Garwood’s home in London and Lanegan’s in Los Angeles. Lanegan wrote all the words. Of “Scarlett”, he said Garwood handed him a piece of music by that name and the lyrics came very quickly.
Not all of it came from the house. Michael Parnin recorded and mixed four songs at Blacksound in Pasadena: “Spaceman” and the three Lanegan wrote alone, “My Shadow Life”, “Upon Doing Something Wrong” and “One Way Glass”. After eight days on the bulk of the album, Garwood said, they went up to Joshua Tree to rehearse for a benefit show. He woke before dawn, wrote “Desert Song” at sunrise and took it down the lane to Rancho de la Luna, where they recorded it that night with Dave Catching and Jon Russo. It closes the album, the one song, as Uncut noted, with no electronics behind the guitar.
“Save Me”, the opener and first single, starts on what the label called “the stuttering click and kick of a primitive drum box”, and Heavenly compared the loops to There’s a Riot Goin’ On and the melodies to Burial and Boards of Canada. Uncut heard a clarinet drift over the drum machine in “My Shadow Life”, which The Wire called the album’s peak. Garwood said the title track’s riff came early one morning during a Los Angeles heatwave, with 109 degrees in the shade. It was the second single, and Loud and Quiet and Punknews both heard in it Lanegan turning from people to heal among animals. Critics heard love, loss and loneliness, and Uncut noted that nearly every song mentions love while none is a love song.
Most reviews were warm; Metacritic averaged 82 from 11. God Is in the TV gave it 9 out of 10, Paste 8.7, and Uncut, Q, Mojo and musicOMH the equivalent of 8. AllMusic’s Mark Deming heard two peers at their best, and Classic Rock a 21st-century blues soaked in atmosphere and dub. Paste found “Scarlett” one idea stretched over three minutes and “Spaceman” out of step, Under the Radar found the mood cohesive but thin, and mxdwn called it a dud. On a run of UK dates that October they played both albums in full; in Glasgow, The Skinny found the songs running together but named the title track the night’s high point. The album spent one week on the UK chart, at No. 68.
With Animals is a good record carried by its best songs, and the complaints fit its middle, not its peaks. The title track, “Save Me” and “My Shadow Life” are blues made from a cassette deck, a drum machine and a few repeated bars under a very low voice, a long way from the guitar record that was Black Pudding. They make a case for that stripped-back, home-taped blues as a style of its own, one that still seems to be waiting for someone to build a body of work on it. Lanegan died at his home in Killarney, Ireland, in February 2022, and Garwood has kept recording, most recently Satin Warrior (2025). The way in is still the title track, built on a riff Garwood found early one morning in a Los Angeles heatwave.
Watch and listen
Players only load when you press play. Their providers may set cookies.