Skip to content
ES
Review Pop rock, Arena rock

Imagine Dragons came back from a year off with five outside producers and a set of singles that ran through ads, trailers, games and the rock chart for a year.

By Elmo Phelge 3 min read

Imagine Dragons stopped in 2016. After six years without a break, Dan Reynolds told Music Week, the band were burnt out, and they wanted to give the world a rest from them, because he thought listeners were tiring of them too. It did not last. Evolve, their third album, came out on Kidinakorner and Interscope on 23 June 2017, and within a year three of its songs had taken turns at the top of Billboard’s rock chart.

Play on Spotify Evolve Imagine Dragons
The Spotify player only loads when you press play. Spotify may set cookies.

The band went back into the studio in the autumn of 2016 with, by the count of their drummer at the time, Daniel Platzman, between 200 and 300 demos. On the self-produced Smoke + Mirrors, he said, one three-minute song could run to 300 tracks of audio. This time, for the first time, they let outside producers take charge and tell them when a take was good enough. Reynolds speaks of “a really minimalistic view”, and told Entertainment Weekly that four instruments could carry as much as fifty. The 11 songs were shared between the Swedish duo Mattman & Robin, Joel Little, John Hill, Tim Randolph and Alex da Kid, who had produced “Radioactive” and worked here with Jayson DeZuzio.

“Believer”, the lead single, came quickly, Reynolds says, in a room with the songwriter Justin Tranter. He told People it was about everything that had hurt him in the previous years, from anxiety in crowds and the weight of the band’s success to depression and ankylosing spondylitis, and about learning to treat that pain as a strength. “Thunder” started at home: Reynolds sang it into his computer in the front room of his house in a single evening, with two of his children audible in the background by his account, then handed it to Alex da Kid. “Whatever It Takes”, produced by Little, nearly went out with another chorus. After months, the band decided it sat too close to Gary Glitter’s “Rock and Roll”, and Reynolds rewrote and re-sang it at home.

Imagine Dragons on a stage lit in blue, the singer at a microphone on the left and a guitarist on the right, with the drum kit between them and raised hands in the crowd below
Imagine Dragons in concert at Mohegan Sun in Uncasville, Connecticut, in November 2017. Photo: Danazar, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Then the songs went out, mostly inside other people’s products. “Believer” played in Nintendo’s first Super Bowl advert, for the Switch, in February 2017, and in June it closed the first trailer for Murder on the Orient Express, to some mockery. “Whatever It Takes” became the official theme of WWE’s Battleground and went into Madden NFL 18. “Believer” spent 29 weeks at No. 1 on Billboard’s Hot Rock Songs chart, then the second-longest run in its history. “Thunder” replaced it in November, and “Whatever It Takes” replaced “Thunder” the following April. Reynolds later said they kept “Natural”, written in the same sessions, off the album because it would have been lost among those three. Evolve reached No. 2 on the Billboard 200 and was nominated for the Grammy for Best Pop Vocal Album.

Critics were split: Metacritic’s average is 47 from seven reviews. Newsday gave it a B+. Rob Harvilla at The Ringer called it shrewd rather than great: probably the band’s best album, and certainly its slickest and shortest. NME heard a small step forward, not the evolution in the title, and The Irish Times preferred the 1980s-style songs, “I’ll Make It Up to You” and “Start Over”, to the big anthems. The Guardian, Rolling Stone, The Independent and The Times gave two stars. Hannah J Davies in the Guardian found the band as anonymous as ever and the album aimed at the people who choose songs for television, with “Whatever It Takes” pitched at sports highlights. Will Hermes in Rolling Stone found Mattman & Robin’s sparse productions a poor fit for Reynolds’ anguish and liked the Alex da Kid song “Yesterday” best.

The reach is the record’s achievement and its problem. Evolve found people who had never gone looking for it: in a console advert, a period-mystery trailer, a wrestling event, a football game and at the top of the rock chart for most of a year. Everything the band said about making it points that way. Producers who keep the sounds few and the takes quick, a chorus swapped out for sounding too familiar, a strong song held back so the first three singles had room: this is an album planned as a run of placements, and the placements won. As a record to sit with, it gives back very little: beyond the singles, the songs critics picked out were “Yesterday” and two 1980s throwbacks. Reynolds had wanted to give listeners a break from Imagine Dragons. Evolve made sure they never got one.

Watch and listen

Players only load when you press play. Their providers may set cookies.

Elmo Phelge relaunched Earbuddy in 2026.

More reviews