Charly Bliss made their first album twice. The Brooklyn band recorded it in 2015 with the producer Justin Pizzoferrato, a month after Dan Shure joined on bass, and then shelved it. “The way we recorded it the first time, we lost all the fun,” the drummer Sam Hendricks said later. Guppy, the second attempt, came out on Barsuk on April 21, 2017: ten songs in just under 30 minutes.
The four go back a long way. Sam and his younger sister Eva Hendricks, the singer and guitarist, grew up in Westport, Connecticut. Spencer Fox, who voiced Dash in The Incredibles as a child, met Eva at 15 outside a Tokyo Police Club show, and Shure, a friend from her high-school theatre days, replaced the original bassist in 2014. After the first sessions they toured, including dates with Veruca Salt, and wrote new songs with Shure in the room. As he tells it, they had set out to make a good indie record and decided instead that their debut should be as strong as it could be. They went back in early 2016 with Kyle Johnson, who had recorded their Soft Serve EP; he produced it with the band and engineered and mixed it at Atomic Sound in New York and Fancy Time Studio in Philadelphia, and Joe LaPorta mastered it at Sterling Sound.
Eva Hendricks writes all the lyrics, and the music is a group effort, fussed over in rounds. She calls “Glitter” a Franken-song: she brought in a demo of a pre-chorus and a chorus, and only the pre-chorus survived the editing. That chorus is a question, whether she is the best or just the first person to say yes. Seconds into “Percolator”, the opener, she announces that she cries all the time, thinks it’s cool and is in touch with her feelings. She told The FADER that a lot of its lines were her making fun of herself for being overdramatic, and that she was trying to make herself laugh. Others throw back things she had been told for years, such as that she was too nice and people would think she was flirting.
“DQ” opens with her laughing at a dead dog and lands on her being too sad to be mean and bound for a job at Dairy Queen; the verse about wetting a trampoline, drunk and bouncing with the band, describes something that really happened. On songs like that, she has said, she builds a version of herself turned up to the extreme so that she can separate herself from it. Not everything is a gag. “Ruby”, released almost a year before the album with a video modelled on public-access television, thanks the therapist who cured her of a debilitating fear of fainting. The “Percolator” video casts the four as superheroes who drop their day jobs to fight evil.
Critics were close to unanimous. Metacritic’s average is 87 from seven reviews. The A.V. Club gave it an A and called it a “nearly flawless exemplar of its kind”, and PopMatters gave it 9 out of 10 and called it “the most fun album released thus far in 2017.” Pitchfork, at 7.8, admired how much bitterness the sugary tunes smuggle in, and Consequence of Sound gave it a B+. The doubts were about range and edges. Exclaim! liked it but found the switches between bright power pop and heavier, grungier songs jarring; Punknews wanted more anger and roughness; the Knoxville News Sentinel thought a couple of tracks were derivative. By December it was second on Newsweek’s list of the year’s albums and ninth on The Ringer’s, and it finished 42nd in the Village Voice’s Pazz & Jop critics’ poll.
The jokes are what make these songs stick. Hendricks’s lines are funny first and hurt second, and in “Glitter” and “DQ” the punchline sits right on the hook, so the part you sing back is the part that stings. That is also the band’s own account of the record: they threw out a version made to be a good indie record because it wasn’t fun, and kept the one where the laugh and the wound arrive together. The heavier turns that bothered Exclaim! are there, but the record is too short for them to drag: only the closer, “Julia”, runs past three and a half minutes. Hendricks has said the title is a sweeter way of calling the band underdogs, and the cover is a bag of goldfish.
Watch and listen
Players only load when you press play. Their providers may set cookies.