Skip to content
ES
Review Soul, Pop
Sam Smith

In the Lonely Hour

Sam Smith's debut was cut in a week with a live band and built around demos. The voice carries all of it, and that is both the strength and the limit.

By Elmo Phelge 2 min read

By the time In the Lonely Hour came out in May 2014, Sam Smith had already been the voice on two hits that belonged to other people: Disclosure’s “Latch”, which reached No. 11 in the UK, and Naughty Boy’s “La La La”, a No. 1. Smith had won the Brits Critics’ Choice award and the BBC’s Sound of 2014 poll, and was already being positioned as a male Adele.

The Spotify player only loads when you press play. Spotify may set cookies.

Smith has called the record a diary about falling for a man who didn’t love them back, and has said that unrequited love is as real as any other kind. The lyrics avoid gendered pronouns. Most of the album was cut in a single week at RAK in London in November 2013: pianist Reuben James, guitarist Ben Thomas, drummer Earl Harvin and bassist Jodi Milliner played seven songs in five days with Smith singing live, and strings were added at Angel Studios a week later. The standard edition runs under 33 minutes, which led Sound on Sound to call it possibly the shortest hit album of the century.

The song that made it is mostly a demo. “Stay with Me” was written quickly in Jimmy Napes’s studio with William Phillips on piano, and about 90 percent of what was released is that demo: a looped drum part recorded on one microphone, tambourine, bass, piano and organ, with the organ middle eight added later. The choir is Smith alone, layered about twenty times. Because the chorus melody resembles Tom Petty’s “I Won’t Back Down”, Petty and Jeff Lynne were added as co-writers in a settlement made public in January 2015; Smith’s side called the resemblance a coincidence. The song reached No. 1 in the UK and No. 2 in the US, and at the Grammys in February 2015 its Darkchild version won Record and Song of the Year.

Around it, the songs share the subject. “Money on My Mind”, the opener, has Two Inch Punch playing everything, and Smith says it was written about a co-writer who wanted a hit to buy a car. “Good Thing”, which Smith calls the darkest song here, came from showing Eg White their text messages. “I’m Not the Only One”, a mid-tempo ballad written in about an hour over Napes’s chords, is about infidelity in a marriage Smith observed. “Life Support” was the last song written with Two Inch Punch, who brought the chords. “Not in That Way”, a ballad with Fraser T Smith on guitar, is the one Smith has called possibly the most important on the album.

The critics agreed on the voice and split on the rest. Metacritic’s average is 62, and the common complaint was that the songs blur together and play it safe. Robert Christgau, against the grain, heard a candid self-portrait. The sales went the other way from the reviews: eight weeks at No. 1 in the UK, a record 67 straight weeks in the top 10 for a debut, and 8.5 million copies worldwide by September 2015.

Sam Smith in a dark jacket and striped shirt singing on a festival stage lit by yellow beams
Sam Smith performing at Lollapalooza on 13 September 2015. Photo: pitpony.photography, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

In the Lonely Hour is a cautious album: ten songs on one subject, most of them built for the voice to carry. The caution is why it worked on that scale, and why it rarely surprises.

Elmo Phelge relaunched Earbuddy in 2026.

More reviews