Skip to content
ES
Review Americana, Folk rock

Without a label, Cory Chisel moved to Nashville and made his next album on tape with Brendan Benson: twelve songs, under 40 minutes, two voices at its centre.

By Elmo Phelge 3 min read

By 2011 Cory Chisel had a well-reviewed major-label album and no label. RCA had shut down Black Seal, the imprint that released Death Won’t Send a Letter in 2009, and Chisel left Wisconsin for Nashville. There he spent time with Brendan Benson of the Raconteurs, whom he had met while making that record and who was starting a label of his own, Readymade. Benson signed him and produced the follow-up. Old Believers came out on 26 June 2012: twelve songs in under 40 minutes, credited, as before, to Cory Chisel and the Wandering Sons.

The Spotify player only loads when you press play. Spotify may set cookies.

The room was Welcome to 1979, the all-analog studio in north Nashville run by the engineer Chris Mara, who recorded the sessions. Benson mixed them and played guitar, keyboards, percussion and sitar. Chisel told Rolling Stone that everything in the place, down to the chairs, felt like a time capsule from 1979, and that tape suited him: a painter needs the edges of a canvas, or he never knows when he is finished. He was trying to get away from the over-thinking of his first album, with the rawness of George Harrison and Elvis Costello records as a guide. By his own account, the sessions ended with him arrested on the last day of recording and held overnight.

The players were mostly Nashville hands. Jon Graboff, on pedal steel and guitar, and the drummer Brad Pemberton had both been in Ryan Adams’s Cardinals. Matt Scibilia also plays drums, Andrew Higley plays piano and organ and arranged the strings, and Mark Watrous adds guitars and violin. Young Hines, a Readymade labelmate, plays reed organ and sings. The other lead voice belongs to Adriel Denae, Chisel’s longtime singing partner, and the record starts with her: “This Is How It Goes” is a prologue that lasts less than a minute and a half.

A band playing in front of a large window at night: a woman at a keyboard on the left, a man in a hat with a guitar in the centre, the audience in silhouette in the foreground
Cory Chisel and the Wandering Sons on stage in Green Bay in July 2012. Photo: DaphneSilver, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

“I’ve Been Accused” went out first, premiered by Rolling Stone in May, which called it soulful. Its repeated line is addressed to an only son. Chisel, whose father was a Baptist minister, told Interview that the line comes out of that relationship, while adding that the song isn’t simply about the two of them. “Never Meant to Love You”, written with Dan Wilson of Semisonic, is a story of love that arrives unplanned. Chisel says he wrote “Please Tell Me” as a message sent through the guitar instead of the phone. The band’s own notes set the dark mood of “Foxgloves” against the brighter “Laura” and call “Over Jordan” a straight traditional blues. “Wood Drake” closes the record at five and a half minutes, its longest song.

The title came from a book. Chisel said the phrase there meant the Orthodox dissenters who refused the church’s constraints, but he used it for someone who has been down a long time and stays steadfast, a journeyman. Critics were warm rather than loud. Hal Horowitz of American Songwriter gave it three and a half stars and handed Benson much of the credit, while noting that the songs touch pop, country and blues without settling into any of them. Gianfranco Marmoro of OndaRock gave it 6.5 and placed Chisel in the line of John Hiatt and John Mellencamp. Illinois Entertainer went furthest and named it its top album of 2012, singling out Denae’s part in it.

The reservation about genre is fair, and it matters less than the method. A songwriter who wanted to stop over-thinking went into a room built around tape and came out with a short, direct record whose first voice is not his own. The people around Chisel are the story here: Benson, who gave him a label and, in his words, helped him focus, and Denae, who sings him in. That turned out to be the pattern. Chisel later co-wrote “The Traveling Kind” with Emmylou Harris and Rodney Crowell, nominated for a Grammy in 2016, and by 2018 he was one third of Traveller with Jonny Fritz and Robert Ellis. Their Western Movies was made at the Refuge, the former monastery in Appleton where he had co-founded an arts foundation.

Elmo Phelge relaunched Earbuddy in 2026.

More reviews