Coke Weed are a five-piece from Bar Harbor, the tourist town on Maine’s Mount Desert Island, and Back to Soft was their third album since 2011. They put it out themselves on 23 July 2013. The title is a small joke at the record’s expense. NPR’s World Cafe and AltSounds both called it the heaviest thing the band had made, and the band’s own press notes present it as a reaction against the album before it.
That album, Nice Dreams (2012), was recorded completely live in ten days with the producer Nick Stumpf of French Kicks and Cavemen. This time the work stretched to nine months, with every overdub, in the notes’ words, “lovingly labored over”. Stumpf came back to produce and mix it. The band had set up its own studio in a barn at Chickadee Hill, a flower farm in the middle of the island, and the record was made at home. Writers heard the change: one found a more electric band than the acoustic one of the earlier records, another a less twangy and more drum-heavy one.
Milan McAlevey wrote the songs, played guitar and shared lead vocals with Nina Donghia. Caleb Davis played the second guitar, Zach Soares bass and Peter Cuffari drums. Before Maine, McAlevey had a band in New York, the Lil’ Fighters, with Walter Martin, later of the Walkmen. Looking back in 2015, McAlevey said that in 2013 the records in heavy rotation were Royal Trux and the San Francisco garage-rock bands of the previous few years. The Velvet Underground, which most reviewers reached for, was an influence McAlevey confirmed to Consequence of Sound.
The comparison starts with the first song. “Sunseekers” opens on a groove that both Consequence and Performer traced to “Sister Ray”, and the Phoenix described a droning riff that Donghia’s voice joins before the song breaks into a noisy stretch in its second minute. Zach Soares directed its video and the one for “Anklet”, which Spin premiered in June and compared to Galaxie 500 and the Paisley Underground, with Donghia’s voice closer to Mazzy Star. Consequence heard the sighing guitar line of “Pale Blue Eyes” in “Anklet”. “Poison”, at track five, has the guitar intro that the Phoenix called almost triumphant, and in the same review “Maryanne” runs on thumping toms and false starts. “Blue Flag”, at 5:23 the longest song, got the first video, in May. “Manchester” closes the album and, as Consequence put it, turns towards country at the last moment. Its video, directed by Jamie Hook and premiered by The A.V. Club in October, plays it straight as a 1990s Alternative Nation clip.
The reviews agreed on the reference points and split on how much they mattered. Most singled out Donghia’s voice, and Performer went as far as Nico. Consequence gave the album a C+: a lean guitar record whose second half is weaker, with “Manchester” the exception. AltSounds, much warmer, predicted it would be one of the year’s most overlooked records. The Phoenix liked the restraint, writing that the band were now “less afraid of being boring”, but found the songs short on tension and narrative. McAlevey later said the album reached the CMJ top 10 that August and, as a self-release, earned back what it cost.
Back to Soft is a borrowed sound, and nobody involved pretended otherwise. What makes it work is the decision behind it. After a record made live in ten days, the band spent nine months adding parts and came out heavier and slower, not busier. On the critics’ evidence the best songs sit at the edges, the “Sister Ray” pulse of “Sunseekers” at the start and the country turn of “Manchester” at the end. Two years later Mary Weaver traded the Velvets for Roxy Music and Bowie, and McAlevey said self-releasing again was no longer affordable.
Watch and listen
Players only load when you press play. Their providers may set cookies.