Skip to content
ES
Review Country pop
Kacey Musgraves

Golden Hour

With two new co-producers and Sheryl Crow's studio, Kacey Musgraves put her wordplay aside for space, vocoders and a disco song. The bet paid off, with limits.

By Elmo Phelge 3 min read

Kacey Musgraves built her name on wordplay. Same Trailer Different Park (2013) won the Grammy for Best Country Album with sharp small-town sketches, and Pageant Material (2015) kept the jokes and dressed them in western kitsch. Golden Hour, released by MCA Nashville on 30 March 2018, is where she put that habit down on purpose. By her own account she was in a funk, between albums and between relationships, and wanted a change. So she stepped away from Shane McAnally and Luke Laird, who had co-produced her first two major-label albums and gave her their blessing.

The Spotify player only loads when you press play. Spotify may set cookies.

Her new partners were Daniel Tashian, of the indie pop band the Silver Seas, and Ian Fitchuk, who had played on Pageant Material. Their first session, in the autumn of 2016, produced “Oh, What a World”, and Musgraves says the blend they found that day, country with something futuristic, set the course for the rest. The three wrote seven of the 13 songs and produced all of them, mostly at Sheryl Crow’s studio outside Nashville, above her horse stable. Pageant Material had been cut by a nine-piece band at three or four songs a day. This time it was usually five or six people, and Fitchuk recalls three full days on “Space Cowboy”. Musgraves called her own job subtraction, loading a track up and erasing until the space was right, and the others nicknamed her the “Ax Man”.

The reference points were not country ones. She told Stereogum she was on a long Bee Gees kick and wondered what a Sade country album would sound like, and Tashian took the Bee Gees lesson as a lyrical one: plain words that turn emotional once the music is under them. The pedal steel and banjo stay, played by Russ Pahl, Dan Dugmore and Todd Lombardo, but the credits also list vocoder, a sampler and Rhodes. “Oh, What a World” opens with Fitchuk’s vocoder and banjo, and “High Horse”, written with Trent Dabbs and Tommy English, is the album’s disco song, one of two that Serban Ghenea mixed. Shawn Everett mixed most of the rest.

Kacey Musgraves in a butterfly-print shirt, holding a sunburst acoustic guitar and touching her ear as she sings into a microphone on stage
Kacey Musgraves at the Palace Theatre in St. Paul, in February 2019. Photo: Andy Witchger, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The personal songs are the plainest. “Butterflies”, written with Laird and Natalie Hemby, was the first thing she wrote after meeting the singer-songwriter Ruston Kelly, whom she married in October 2017; they divorced in 2020. “Slow Burn” is about taking things slowly, in a career and in love. “Mother” lasts 1:18: she wrote most of it alone one night, on LSD, after a text from her mother, and it was recorded live at the piano. She kept small flaws in that vocal and in “Rainbow”, a piano ballad written years earlier with McAnally and Hemby, which she had shelved after it was played at her grandmother’s funeral and brought back because the album needed an ending.

Critics were close to unanimous: Metacritic’s average was 89 from 18 reviews. The Guardian and the Independent gave it five stars, and Alexis Petridis picked out “Lonely Weekend” on a record aimed at crossover that never strains for it. The reservations came from the same place as the praise. Pitchfork, at 8.7, missed the precise detail of her 2013 breakthrough, Consequence of Sound named the toned-down wit as its one weakness, Uncut found it less pointed than the two albums before it, and Under the Radar thought she had leaned too far into pop. Robert Christgau gave it a B+: he found its evenness both its commercial strength and the reason he stopped short of full praise. It topped the Pazz & Jop poll, won Album of the Year at the CMA Awards and, in February 2019, all four Grammys it and its songs were up for, Album of the Year among them.

The acclaim is mostly deserved. “Slow Burn”, “Space Cowboy”, “Mother” and “Rainbow” are the songs critics singled out, and the method behind them, a small team with time and a producer willing to delete, gives the album the cohesion reviewers kept noticing. The trade has a cost. With the wit turned down, the songs lean on mood, and the critics who held back agreed that the mood rarely shifts. That makes Golden Hour a strong, carefully made album rather than one of the few that define their decade, whatever Rolling Stone’s list of the 500 greatest albums said when it placed it at 270 in 2020. The trio from that first session has produced each of her studio albums since: Star-Crossed, Deeper Well and, in May 2026, Middle of Nowhere.

Watch and listen

Players only load when you press play. Their providers may set cookies.

Elmo Phelge relaunched Earbuddy in 2026.

More reviews